Whatever happened to Gallic flair Posted almost 12 years ago

Another Six Nations has been played out and Wales deservedly took the title and a 3rd Northern Hemisphere Grand Slam in seven years. They defeated a French team totally unrecognisable in performance from the one which contested the World Cup final.

Wales are to be congratulated on beating the best of the northern hemisphere but it is fair to say that this has been anything but a vintage Six Nations and the three games on the final day did nothing to change this view.

The Welsh approach has been a model of composure in moments of pressure and the humility they have shown before, during and after games has been a credit to them and a marked difference from recent years. The so-called mind games leading up to Test matches have stopped.

This can only be good news as the effects on the opposition can be unpredictable and it sometimes demonstrates to me a feeling of insecurity in the perpetrators. Wales’s focus appears to have been fully on performance on the field and this has helped them survive the tough times when they were down to fourteen men against both Ireland and England.

Wales’s stated aim is now to begin challenging and beating the Southern Hemisphere teams. It is a laudable and logical one but they will need to develop more adaptability with the ball , rediscover the inherent Welsh midfield creativity and recover the massive enthusiasm and ambition they showed in their World Cup performances.

I would bet this morning that even the French cannot explain their Six Nations campaign. They appear to have lost complete direction in how they wish to play the game. Their approach last weekend was demonstrated in the early moments when Beauxis ( what has Trinh-Duc done to alienate his coach ? ) attempted a drop goal from 55 metres that predictably , given his efforts v England , hardly left the ground. The French teams of old would have recognised a great counter-attacking opportunity but in their current pragmatic mode it probably never even crossed their mind !

Leaving aside their notorious unpredictability of performance, the French mindset has dramatically changed over the years and their overall approach , so distinctive in the past , has now become very uniform in comparison with other teams. Physicality has superseded creativity in midfield and territory has largely cancelled out counter attack.

This can be traced back at least 10 years when DISCIPLINE became the buzz word for the National side. I took this to mean that it signified a behavioural change to the needless giving away of silly penalties that often used to cost them dear. I was wrong ! It was to place a great deal more structure on their game ( a consequence of professional coaching perhaps ? ) .

So at the same time that Stade Toulouse especially and others were capable of playing in a variety of ways and could explode in a kaleidoscope of flamboyant , thrilling and winning rugby when the opportunities arose the National side were trimming their sails to a set piece , defence and territorial game.

Now , no-one is undermining the importance of these factors , but they will only take a side so far on the World stage over a period of time. More importantly this approach appeared to be totally at odds with the talents of the players available and how French coaches have traditionally interpreted the game down the years.

The French used to be many neutral supporters’ favourite team to watch and learn from but not any more, which is bitterly disappointing.


I feel that this Six Nations French team have proved the validity of this.

Enter your email address to continue reading

We frequently post interesting articles and comment from our world class content providers so please provide us with your email address and we will notify you when new articles are available.

We'll also get in touch with various news and updates that we think will interest you. We promise to not spam, sell, or otherwise abuse your address (you can unsubscribe at any time).

See all News & Opinions videos


comments powered by Disqus

Brian Ashton has credentials as both player and coach. He started playing rugby at Lancaster Royal Grammar School and progressed through age and club grades. While Brian played representative rugby for Lancashire, England North, and the Barbarians it is as a coach that he has made the more significant impact. He has coached at club and international level since 1980, including 2 years as England head coach. Brian is currently Technical Director of Rugby at Fylde RFC in Lancashire and is widely regarded as one of the most visionary coaches in the global game.

Topic News & Opinions
Applicable to Coaches  

Related articles

The Lions and Wallabies need some x-factor

Brian Ashton looks ahead to the Lions tour and prays that both sides play the creative game that is part of their history

The Six Nations So Far

Former England Head Coach, Brian Ashton reviews the performance of the teams so far this Six Nations

Brian Ashton on his Rugby Coaching Journey

Brian Ashton talks about how he got into coaching, those that influenced him and how he learned to become one of the game’s most respected coaches.

Consistent Leinster Triumphs

Despite having a family interest in Ulster (my wife works for the company that provides their playing/leisure kit) it was fitting and important that the side who were consistently prepared to play the most varied and challenging rugby throughout the tournament triumphed.

Ulster and Clermont to meet in the Heineken final

Forget the occasion, forget the opposition, clear heads are needed in the semi-final of a major cup competition says Brian Ashton.