We haven't won for a bit so can we change the rules please Posted almost 12 years ago

The headquarters of European Rugby Cup Ltd are in Dublin, making it perhaps fitting that Leinster have come to dominate the Heineken Cup. Victory over Ulster in Saturday’s all-Ireland final at Twickenham would be their third success in the tournament in the last four seasons following victories over Northampton last year and Leicester in 2009.

This is the 17th year of the Heineken Cup and the list of nine winners will not be added to because Ulster defeated Colomiers in the 1999 final. Whoever prevails in the west of London, Irish hands will be on the trophy for the fifth time in seven years after Munster’s successes in 2006 and 2008.

Teams have tended to have success in the Heineken Cup in clusters. Leicester’s two titles came in consecutive years from 2001, Wasps prevailed in 2004 and 2007 and Munster twice in three seasons, a feat repeated by Leinster in Cardiff three years ago.

The only consistently successful side has been Toulouse, who have won the competition a record four times and reached the final on six occasions. Ireland’s recent record in Europe has so spooked the leading French and English clubs that they are threatening to give the required notice of two years to pull out of the tournament.

They are demanding participating teams be determined on a league rather than a national basis. Under the current system, France and England each supply between six and seven clubs, Ireland and Wales three or four teams with the two professional sides in both Scotland and Italy automatically qualifying.

The French and English clubs want eight teams each to qualify from the three major leagues in Europe, the Aviva Premiership, the Top 14 and the RaboDirect Pro 12, a change that, based on this season’s table, would leave Italy unrepresented in next season’s Heineken Cup and Glasgow waving the saltire.

The Top 14 and Premiership clubs do not see why they should have to go through the rigours of a competitive qualifying process for the Heineken Cup each season, also having relegation to worry about, while the likes of Leinster and Munster can put their feet up and only field their leading players in Irish derbies.

There would also be a bigger chunk of change for the French and English grandees, but the RaboDirect nations are entitled to ask what the French, Toulouse apart, and they were distinctly average this season, bring to the Heineken Cup.

While three Irish provinces and four English clubs have won the tournament, only Brive in 1997 have succeeded from the Top 14 in addition to Toulouse. Many French teams regard qualifying for the Heineken Cup as more important than making an impact in it and focus on their 26-match league.

Yet this is the first year that both England and France have not been represented in the final and some of their teams have been distinctly underwhelming: Leicester shipped 41 points to Ulster in Ravenhill, Northampton were hit for 50 by Munster in Milton Keynes, the free-spending Racing Metro lost their three home matches and Biarritz lost to Treviso.

Ulster took an unusual route to the final, qualifying for the last eight as one of the best group runners-up having lost away to Leicester and Clermont. They won their quarter-final in Munster before subduing Edinburgh in the Dublin semi-final.

Ulster, whose success in 1999 was down, in part, to the English clubs boycotting the tournament, had for 11 years afterwards never got past the pool stage. Hard to beat at Ravenhill, they were shocking travellers but they are now fortified with South Africa steel: Johann Muller, Ruan Pienaar, Pedrie Wannenburg and Stefan Terblanche – not to forget the New Zealand prop John Afoa – have helped inject greater consistency and less excitability.

Leinster have in recent years preferred one major overseas player. Rocky Elsom was their inspiration when they won the Heineken Cup for the first time and this year Brad Thorn has made an immediate impact. At 37, the All Blacks second row will become the oldest player to appear in a final and, having won the Super 14 and World Cup, he is looking for a unique treble.

Leinster are the favourites, but they were a year ago when they trailed Northampton 22-6 at half-time before the outside-half Jonathan Sexton prompted an unlikely revival. He was at it again last month as Leinster came from behind to defeat Clermont Auvergne.

The paradox about Sexton is why he so assertive for Leinster but often dithery for Ireland. That raises the question why Ireland are struggling to replicate their provincial success at international level.

Leinster are a rounded side, competent in the set-pieces, strong at the breakdown and blessed with guile and pace behind. Ulster are not mutli-dimensional, but they are organised and strong defensively. It threatens to be tense and tight on a ground where Ireland were humbled in the Six Nations two months ago, but Sexton threatens to be the difference.

Enter your email address to continue reading

We frequently post interesting articles and comment from our world class content providers so please provide us with your email address and we will notify you when new articles are available.

We'll also get in touch with various news and updates that we think will interest you. We promise to not spam, sell, or otherwise abuse your address (you can unsubscribe at any time).

See all News & Opinions videos


comments powered by Disqus

Paul Rees was born in Cardiff and has been a full-time writer on rugby union since 1986, first for the South Wales Echo, then Wales and Sunday and, from 2001, the Guardian and the Observer, having contributed to the former on a freelance basis since 1988. He has covered every World Cup since 1991 and five Lions tours. When time allows, he also write on cricket, mainly Glamorgan. And away from work, he a season-ticket holder at Arsenal, watching them home and away, including the European Champions League final against Barcelona in Paris in 2006.

Topic News & Opinions
Applicable to Coaches  

Related articles

Heineken Cup Final Preview - A Splash of Panache is Required

The all French final will see few Frenchmen compete for Europe’s premier club trophy. Paul Rees analyses how the final will likely play out

The Fickleness of Fate

Chris Robshaw isn’t going to Australia with the Lions, Sam Warburton is and as captain. Before the Six Nations finale, the story looked very different.

What Price Two All French Finals

Paul Rees expects that the new increase to the French salary cap will create an even bigger gap between the haves and have-nots of European rugby

Wales alone wouldn't beat the Wallabies

Wales may have won the Six Nations but recent history has shown that they alone won’t have enough to beat the Wallabies.

Wales's Defence put to the Test in Cardiff

Expect low risk rugby in this weekend’s Six Nations decider as both sides are likely to attmept to defend their way to victory