Lancaster’s collective cost England players a Lions place Posted almost 11 years ago

In time honoured fashion, the media tried its best to create some drama out of the Lions squad announcement. But in truth, the squad near enough picked itself. Following a Six Nations which threw up so little quality, the known strengths of key players were always like to be the deciding factor. They mostly emanate from Wales and Ireland, some of whom toured South Africa in 2009 and will still be hurting after the series defeat.

Watch Warren Gatland’s exclusive interview with The Rugby Site here

One or two selections did catch the eye. Maku Vunipola has had a sensational season, with handling skills to match a three-quarter as well as a real physical presence. He could become one of the all time greats, whilst the selection of Matt Stevens has a tinge of the romantic attached.

Outside his mobility, passing skill and ability on either side of the scrum, he is highly regarded off field and will fit the Lions ethos perfectly. His successful return from a two year suspension is one of Rugby and team sports great moments.

Another big talking point was the selection of only two fly-halves. However, it seemed as if it was an excuse to put forward the merits of Jonny Wilkinson. I may upset some misty- eyed fans, but his best rugby was a while ago, notwithstanding his dead ball kicking exploits and occasional hard tackle.

Gatland has been super-smart, entertaining the possibility of Jonny touring at some point but not really wanting him as a midweek fly-half .The Lions midweek team will want to play to their absolute limits, and frankly to accommodate Wilkinson these days you have to form your strategy around him, playing big men on limited charges and standing him in the pocket. Johnny Sexton is by far the best 10 in the Northern Hemisphere, and the mere mention of Wilko is a sad reflection on the lack of talent elsewhere.

Back row selections are the last real bone of contention with the omission of Tom Wood and Chris Robshaw, both fine players. Of course there was very stiff competition, as there always is for these positions. The problem for Wood and Robshaw, and the same applies to an extent to England’s back three and midfield, is that England has become something of a ‘collective’ under Lancaster.

What I mean by that is that they have suppressed their individuality for the team cause. That can quite possibly be a good thing for England, we shall see, but when looking for something special and Lion-like, you come up short. On balance though, I think Gatland is justified, and I certainly think that Leicester’s Tom Croft will be a Lions starter – his lineout jumping is unmatched, and his pacey running is highly impressive.

Hence, in some quarters, people think that England may have only one starter in a Lions shirt, that being Croft. The conservatism of the national team and some Premiership sides will not have helped. This also may say something for the age and experience levels of many England players, and the longer term success of the Welsh and Irish players who dominate selection.

Whatever one’s opinion, Gatland will carry the confidence of four nations. The Australians, despite superior levels of skill especially in the backs, will be very wary of the Lions great physical strength, and I expect there to be power plays all across the park, as Gatland knows that’s a battle he can win and will form the platform he wants to have in order to win the series.

Has Lancaster’s England project been detrimental to the Lions hopes of his players? Comments below…

Enter your email address to continue reading

We frequently post interesting articles and comment from our world class content providers so please provide us with your email address and we will notify you when new articles are available.

We'll also get in touch with various news and updates that we think will interest you. We promise to not spam, sell, or otherwise abuse your address (you can unsubscribe at any time).

See all News & Opinions videos


comments powered by Disqus

Hallers played for Oxford University, Bath & Harlequins and represented England in 23 test matches, including the Rugby World Cup final against Australia in 1991. Simon, a former RFU Council member, is an investment banker in the City of London and also Executive Director of Esher RFC.

Topic News & Opinions
Applicable to Coaches  

Related articles

Mind Games - Weight of Expectation

Simon Halliday previews this weekend’s RBS Six Nations Finale. Three teams alive and able to claim the title. Game on…


Simon Halliday talks RBS Six Nations. An interesting and as always brutally honest perspective from a passionate Englishman. Someone who understands the heat of battle and lives the game today as much as he ever has.

Enjoy and as always please do join the discussion…

Patriot Games – A Critical 6 Nations Weekend

Read Simon Halliday’s preview on this weekend’s critical 6 Nation’s matches as he considers key aspects that will define the weekend..

An Englishman’s View

Simon Halliday gives us an Englishman’s view of the challenges facing Stuart Lancaster and his team as they ready themselves for one of the most anticipated RBS Six Nations in recent memory.

The art of being smart - coaches everywhere under spotlight in RWC lead up

Simon Halliday shares with us his thoughts around the Autumn Internationals to date and what they tell us about form and contenders for the 2015 RWC.