Is the congested calendar slowly killing the game? Posted 6 months ago


Photo: The Rugby Site

Is the congested calendar slowly killing the game?

Exeter Chiefs’ recent Aviva Premiership victory over Sale Sharks was not exactly easy on the eye.

As a result I doubt many made it all the way through to the end of the game where arguably the most compelling contribution was made by Chiefs boss Rob Baxter whose words should serve as a warning call to anyone currently involved in the elite game.

“I would love to sit here and apologise,” he said in the immediate aftermath of his side’s largely uneventful 10-6 win at the AJ Bell Stadium. “Obviously what we want on TV and what we want in the Premiership is more rugby played, more tries scored and a higher level of game."

“The problem is on the back of what we have had the last few weeks, to come here to Sale on a Friday night against a team that are very good here at home and have always made it difficult for us, we’ve actually had to come here and talk about how we were going to grind the win out, make the win happen and that actually became more important than the performance.”

His words will have washed over most still tuned in to BT Sport as the majority of such post-match analysis fails to register on the Richter scale but this statement deserves greater attention and wider exposure amid the ongoing debate about the physical and mental demands of what is quite clearly an over-congested season.

In fact, it should be setting off alarms at Premiership Rugby, World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union and in the offices of every other stakeholder in the game.

In essence, Baxter is saying that the brutal nature of the northern hemisphere season and the ridiculous demands on his players – who had criss-crossed the continent in the Champions Cup over the previous two weeks – has a detrimental effect on the type of rugby his side can produce week to week.

He is also admitting that this in turn has a negative impact on the quality of the finished product and makes it impossible for his side to deliver the kind of eye-popping spectacle that fans, Premiership Rugby and TV and commercial partners crave.

Observers ‘outside’ the game have long warned of a similar toll and the players themselves are also slowly finding their voice on the subject as they bid to secure their physical wellbeing and their future earning potential.

But rarely, if at all, does a coach weigh in on the subject, admit the sport is beating itself up and suggest his team are perhaps playing too many matches that in turn pay his salary.

It is a brave call and one from someone who perhaps sees beyond the balance sheet to the people whose lives he manages and the sport he loves.

If you want further evidence of the madness of the over-crowded global calendar then cast an eye over the side that the Barbarians will field against New Zealand at Twickenham on Saturday.

Not one Home Nations player features in a squad and what could have been a great advert for the game will be little more than a contest for Kiwi bragging rights with the Baa-Baas set to draw on a squad including 13 New Zealanders, nine South Africans, three Australians and just one European player – Italian flanker Simone Favaro.

Without doubt the Barbarians squad is brimming with talent – with recent All Black wing Julian Savea a notable inclusion – but you can understand the All Blacks’ murmured frustrations at the familiar faces they will face in a fixture that is part of the 125th anniversary celebrations for the New Zealand Rugby Union.

It is a major missed opportunity and another sad reflection of the damaging lack of harmony in the modern game with various parties unable to provide a workable framework or one that even allows for the kind of breathing space that would ensure the release of high-profile Home Nations players.

It is sadly some way from the epic clash between the same sides back in 1973 when an entirely Home Nations-based Barbarians side featuring future legends of the game such as Gareth Edwards, Willie John McBride and Mike Gibson recorded a memorable victory and notched ‘the greatest try ever scored’ in the process.

Watch it now

We may have been blessed recently with a great Test series showdown between the All Blacks and the British & Irish Lions, but imagine a similarly star-studded Barbarians side featuring the biggest names in the northern hemisphere, enthused by the freedom to play that comes with the famous black and white hooped jersey, taking on the world champions at a capacity Twickenham?

What fun everyone, fans old and new, could have had.

If you wanted even more evidence of the somewhat ludicrous nature of the current season then scan the fixtures elsewhere this weekend.

The Anglo-Welsh Cup, a development competition for the leading English and Welsh clubs that often struggles in terms of profile, kicks off without a key element – the Welsh clubs.

Wales’ regional sides will be doing battle with their PRO14 rivals in the latest round of that cross-border competition before joining the Anglo-Welsh contest a week later. It is almost laughable.

Enough is enough. It’s time to put individual interests aside.

Action must be taken to preserve the welfare of the players, the commercial viability of the game, the reputation of those in charge and the very future of the sport. Before it is too late.

The Rugby site is the only online coaching resource to offer a truly global perspective, subscribe for 12 months – now at a lower price point.

Enter your email address to continue reading

We frequently post interesting articles and comment from our world class content providers so please provide us with your email address and we will notify you when new articles are available.

We'll also get in touch with various news and updates that we think will interest you. We promise to not spam, sell, or otherwise abuse your address (you can unsubscribe at any time).


comments powered by Disqus

Graham Jenkins is a freelance sports journalist who has been reporting around the rugby globe for over 20 years. A former editor of the leading rugby union website, he is a veteran of five World Cups and cites England’s 2003 triumph as the most memorable moment of his professional career - closely followed by a night out with Toulon owner Mourad Boudjellal.

Topic News & Opinions
Applicable to Coaches   Players   Others   Supporters and fans  

Related articles

Major League Rugby proves the land of opportunity

Latest edition of the US Major league kicks off next weekend, writer Graham Jenkins talks to ex Wasps and now San Diego Legions coach Rob Hoadley about the benefits of coaching overseas and in the US Major league.

Top players must be hungry for homework

Preparing the body for the physical demands of the elite game is just part of the challenge for the northern hemisphere’s finest with the mental preparation arguably just as pivotal in not only securing a victory but also prolonging a career at the top. Writer Graham Jenkins looks at what is expected of elite players outside the training pitch and gym as they prepare for big matches.

Does ‘retrospective refereeing’ do the game any good?

England’s narrow 12-6 victory over Wales attracted an impressive UK TV audience of 6.4m to underline the appeal of what is billed as ‘rugby’s greatest championship’. Writer Graham Jenkins examines how rugby failed to capitalise on its popularity at Twickenham where the officials and not the players stole the headlines.

Continuity the key to continued success for England

In a sporting landscape where the news of a coach losing their job often appears as common as a kick off, word of one being rewarded with a contract extension certainly commands attention. In his latest article, Graham Jenkins evaluates Eddie Jones’ England head coach contract extension and what the succession plan could be.

The benefit of coaching out of your comfort zone

Ronan O’Gara is set to swap French Top 14 side Racing 92 for the Crusaders in New Zealand next month in a bold bid to improve as a coach and broaden his understanding of the game. Writer Graham Jenkins looks at O’Gara’s motivation for heading down under to the Crusaders.