France is set to win the ugly Grand Slam Posted about 12 years ago

Oh, how we all long for the return of French flair, for those crazy moments of Gallic genius, for the power and the beauty, for something from another time. Oh well, it may be another season of disappointment. The new coach Philippe Saint-Andre is about as romantic as a text book.

He likes organisation and discipline. It is not a coincidence that Saint-Andre spent time coaching at Gloucester and Sale, in the meat-and-potatoes districts of English rugby. He is something of an Anglophile. He is like Pierre Berbizier or Bernard Laporte in his need to impose structure.

If the French want want flair, then maybe they shouldn’t have given Marc Lievremont such a hard time. Everyone climbed on his back, but I think he was a smart operator. I reckon he deliberately provoked the players at the World Cup.

When the French fear the worst, when they are scared of getting a hiding, when their manhood is questioned, then they are dangerous. Lievremont settled on that early. He also studied every single New Zealand move and was prepared to emulate it.

Lievremont said that France couldn’t beat us twice in New Zealand at the World Cup, but they could beat us once. And so I think he set up his team to fail against us in the pool stages. He is very smart, in my view. Marc Lievremont is nobody’s fool.

Saint-Andre is not proven and he has made some interesting selections for the opening game against Italy. Maxime Mermoz is a player whom the All Blacks really rated, good on attack and defence, and an excellent decision maker.

But Mermoz has lost his place to Wesley Fofana, an exciting ball carrier and a teammate of Aurelien Rougerie at Clermont. Is Saint-Andre looking for club combinations? There are five from Clermont and five from Toulouse in his initial selection.

That means that Imanol Harinordoquy has also been dropped. You could argue that Harinordoquy, the best in the world when he feels like it, and Mermoz were two of France’s best three players at the World Cup.

But France are always a threat. They take their emotional force from their scrummage and although their lineout can be predictable, it is still very hard to stop. It sets up so much for them. Yachvili kicks from the base of lineouts that have been shortened to increase the number of chasers.

France also runs a move where the hooker peels off the back of a lineout drive. He can then run to the openside or feed the scrum-half who will hit Fofana on a short ball or run it behind him to Trinh-Duc who will open out the move wide. They have five or six options off the one play and you have to read their body language and adapt quickly.

France also defends very well. Trinh-Duc is a perceived weakness, but you can tell from the way he carries into contact that he’s not scared. The back three is powerful and Rougerie recovers very well in defence.

Usually they hold and push. You have to commit them on the inside or they will have five men on the winger. But they also like to pull out the rush defence from time to time, particularly against England, who are maybe slower to react in midfield than some other teams.

But don’t expect to be taken to the moon this year. Some of the fault lies with French club rugby. In the main there is a lot of kicking and driving of short balls in the Top 14. They have the athletes still, but the club scene is not a field for growing French flair any more.

The amount of rugby in France also means that the national coach has less time with his team than almost every other major nation. This may be where we see the best of Saint-Andre. He does not get too dirty on the training field, but he does take the wider view. He will try to change the landscape and he is dead right. The national team is at a huge disadvantage to other countries.

But France is so strong that they could well win the Grand Slam this year. The schedule helps them in the next couple of months, but it may not help Saint-Andre change the structure in the long term.

Prediction: 1.France 2.Ireland 3.England, Wales 5.Scotland 6.Italy

Enter your email address to continue reading

We frequently post interesting articles and comment from our world class content providers so please provide us with your email address and we will notify you when new articles are available.

We'll also get in touch with various news and updates that we think will interest you. We promise to not spam, sell, or otherwise abuse your address (you can unsubscribe at any time).

See all News & Opinions videos


comments powered by Disqus

_Graham Henry on Wayne Smith:_ "Wayne is the best coach I have ever coached with. He has a huge work ethic, does lots of research and has a great feel for the game. At the moment he is the defence coach and is also involved with our counter attacking strategy. He is a very thoughtful man and takes a major interest in how we use turnover ball. He has been going around with a little camera which he uses to track individual players for a whole game. It has proved quite embarrassing for some. There is nowhere to hide and the players soon learn where they have to step up. Top bloke."

Topic News & Opinions
Applicable to Coaches  

Related articles

Australia’s three major test failures

The reason that even some Aussies are giving Argentina a chance in Perth is the current failings of their team at three major areas of test match rugby.

The Stats Do Lie by Wayne Smith

Wayne Smith explains why the stats that you see during and after a game are as useful as a chocolate teapot

Australia will attack All Black heart

Wayne Smith says the new Wallaby coach is a good tactician and believes that the selction for the first test makes a lot of sense

Beale’s Boots and the Lucky Lions

Wayne Smith tips Australia to level the series in Melbourne

Ben Youngs must start for the Lions

Wayne Smith praises the rugby being played by the Lion’s thus far and thinks that Ben Youngs must be included in the starting lineup.