JG's Round-Up

Our undercover man inside the game

almost 2 years ago

Captain Fantastic

It was pleasing to see so many of the Springboks “injured 21” return to the field of play in this weekend’s narrow loss to the Wallabies. Concern has been voiced over the injury sustained by the Boks illustrious captain John Smit but early reports from the South African camp have dismissed suggestions that Smit had torn elbow ligaments and will miss the Rugby World Cup.

The Wallaby scrum dominated the Springboks up front in Saturday’s Test, but only after Jannie du Plessis left the field and Smit moved to tight head. Bismarck is breathing down Smit’s neck in the race for the first choice hooker position but Captain Fantastic brings much more to the team. Smit’s leadership skills were proven during the 1st Test of the British & Irish Lions series against the Springboks in Durban in 2009.

If concerns were to persist over his availability for the World Cup, he could still make a significant contribution from the sideline as Andy Dalton did for the All Blacks in 1987. However, if Smit proves his fitness would he be better starting with the number 16 on his back?

“Embarrassing”

England’s dominance at the set piece in Saturday’s match against Wales counted for nothing, with the Welsh exacting revenge for last week’s loss at Twickenham. The English forwards did not have it all their own way though with the Welsh back, row led by Sam Warburton, dominating the breakdown.

With Jamie Roberts and Mike Phillips both sin-binned, England had a one man advantage for 20 minutes of the 2nd half. Despite this Wales outscored England on the try count for the second weekend in a row and the English attack again lacked incision. The Welsh fitness training camp last month in Spala, Poland appeared to pay dividends at they finished the game strongly.

In Toby Flood’s words “it was embarrassing”. Johnno was apoplectic. While these games may be mere warm-ups for the main event in New Zealand, there can be no denying that they offer teams the opportunity to enter the World Cup with momentum. England’s last game of the August series is against Ireland in Dublin on August 27th and this game has now become a must win for them.

Who would you pick to start for England, Mike Tindall or Manu Tuilagi?

Japan

Following last month’s milestone Pacific Nations victory over Fiji, Japan ran Italy close at Stadio Manuzzi on Saturday. They continue to progress under coach John Kirwan, whose long term goals include making the last 8 of the 2015 tournament and then the final of the 2019 World Cup to be held in Japan. Is JK smoking something?

Japan’s RWC record is nothing to be encouraged by. Although they have attended all 6 World Cups they have only one pool win to their name, against Zimbabwe in 1991.

They have been drawn in Pool A for RWC 2011 and will not be fancied against host New Zealand or France. However, having beaten Tonga in July and Canada twice in 2009 when they last played, Kirwan will no doubt be eyeing both games as opportunities for the Cherry Blossoms to improve their Cup record and continue progress towards achieving their long term goals.

Yellow Cards

Four matches in to the Tri Nations we have yet to see a player sin-binned. At the same stage in last year’s competition 7 yellow cards had been awarded, with Bakkies Botha having the dubious distinction of receiving 2 of them.

Rugby union is a game best contested by two teams of 15 players each. Long may this trend continue.

Injuries continue to mount

With the start of the Rugby World Cup a matter of 25 days away, the injury count continues to rise. The failure of Juan Marin Hernandez to make the Argentina squad after knee ligament surgery in March is a loss not just to the Pumas but to the tournament. Hernandez was one of the stand-out performers of the 2007 World Cup in France, where Argentina finished third.

Amongst some of the higher profile players currently injured are Matthew Rees, Gavin Henson, Lewis Moody, Andy Sheridan, John Smit, Frans Steyn, Hugo Southwell, Maxime Mermoz, Wycliff Palu and Drew Mitchell.

Engage

In March 2005 Matt Hampson was on the cusp of realising his rugby dream of playing for England. He was training with the England U21 squad when a scrum collapsed, with Hampson taking its full weight on his neck. His neck was dislocated and his spinal cord trapped and he was left a tetraplegic. “Engage” was the last word Matt heard before his accident.

6 years on and Hampson has moved into a house custom-built for him by his father. His passion for rugby is undiminished. His sense of humour is remarkable. Paul Kimmage has ghost-written Matt’s book “Engage” which is published this week.

With so much focus on Rugby World Cup, referee errors, controversially coloured away jerseys and other such matters, Matt Hampson’s story provides a reality check and should remind those fortunate enough to play our great game to enjoy it no matter what the result.

Posted under News & Opinions

6 Comments

Report as inappropriate

David Ardley

almost 2 years ago

“Who would you pick to start for England, Mike Tindall or Manu Tuilagi”? Tuilagi for me. I think Tindall would be a better bench replacement – a wise ‘super sub’ if you will. To not take advantage of the game when Wales were two players down was unacceptable at test level – but well played Wales for excellent endeavour and self belief. The point about injuries is always an issue…and at the extreme end your story about Matt and his courage brings it all home. I look forward to buying/reading the book and by doing so help contribute some monies to the cause.

Report as inappropriate

almost 2 years ago

You make a valid point about Tindalls experience David. This is a young England back-line and even a slow wise sage can have a big impact. However, we shouldn’t ignore the significance of the inside centre / 2nd five-eighth (the 12!) in this debate. Rugby history is littered with outstanding midfield pairings and to look at one component in isolation might be over-simplifying it. Riki Flutey will be pushing for selection in this berth and might have the speed and creativity to combine effectively with Tindalls raw power and experience. If Flutey can perform to the level he did for the Lions in South Africa in 2009 he will be hard to ignore. These are effectively trial games and combinations are being tested. It would be premature to dismiss England on the basis of Saturday’s game– even if it was the first time they failed to score a try in a game since a dour encounter against Scotland in March 2010. For the second time in three years they were top try scorers in this year’s RBS 6 Nations. Martin Johnson is confident that Lewis Moody will be fit to play against Ireland on August 27th and perhaps this will allow Tindall to play without the burden of the captaincy. It may be difficult to leave a World Cup winner from 2003 on the bench when things get serious next month.

Report as inappropriate

Michael Goldstein

almost 2 years ago

Tuiliagi for sure. Every side needs a Pacific Islander “ringer”. Check out the ABs! The winning side will need some pace and a cutting edge. Tindall gives you neither.

Report as inappropriate

Peter Graham

almost 2 years ago

Interesting point about centre partnerships. How about ROG and BOD for Ireland, they looked good this afternoon for the 15 mins or so ROG was on the pitch.

Report as inappropriate

almost 2 years ago

Thanks Peter.

Like other coaches, Declan Kidney has used the August matches to experiment with different combinations. With O’Driscoll & D’Arcy both returning from injury on Saturday, it was expecting too much for them to fire on their first outing.

It would be a big call for O’Gara to start at 12 in the more important games to come over the next couple of months. However, with the injury record of O’Driscoll & D’Arcy it is easy to understand why Kidney needs to keep his options open.

Paddy Wallace has his detractors but is the more likely replacement at 12, while McFadden continues to be understudy at outside centre.

Given their 3 recent defeats, the Irish need a win against England on Saturday to enter RWC with any momentum or semblance of confidence. The key game in Group C of RWC was believed to be Australia v Ireland, if the Irish are not careful their game against Italy may become the crucial encounter for them.

Report as inappropriate

Simon Halliday

almost 2 years ago

JG , its great to read your wise words. The Pre World Cup matches have told me nothing that i didnt already know – that the ABs are the stand out team , Aus have all the talent , SA the brawn , and any of the Northern Hemisphere teams can threaten on the day .Watch out for Samoa , they were v good at Twickenham last nov . This shd be a good tournament , where the winner will really deserve it .Not like 2007 when there ws hardly a game worth watching , or 2003 when everyone was scared of England !!