75% Dan is Still the Main Man
Steve Hansen has been around the All Blacks too long to make the mistakes I made when picking my first New Zealand squad in 2004. We went with too many players who had been around. We were finding our way as coaches and thought that test match experience was all-important. It helps, but when players are coming to the end, they are not going to get any better. Steve is already looking to the future.
I still expect him to pick his experienced players for the first test against Ireland this summer. I imagine Sam Whitelock will pair up with Ali Williams in a pack without surprises and that Andy Ellis will start at half back. But the young players that have been brought into the squad are all part of the evolution.
I don’t think you could call it a surprise to say that Sonny Bill Williams is likely to start. It is sensible to give Ma’a Nonu a rest. He’s hitting a wall. He’s played 18 months of football without a break. So Sonny will probably start against Ireland. That will get Ma’a moving again and by the Tri Nations he will be raring to go.
There has been talk of moving Dan Carter out to 12 and, looking back 8 years, that is where he started in my first match in charge against England. But I’m sure Dan will be selected at 10. At the moment there is a subconscious protection of his body going on that even he may not be fully aware of. Dan is playing 75% with the reins on.
But as the international season comes around and championship football returns, Dan will get back to his best. He’s not lost the ability. I am sure Steve sees him as a 10 who can cover 12. That gives selection flexibility, but Dan will be selected at first five, as well as Aaron Cruden is playing.
Cruden has been outstanding for the Chiefs and it is good to see so many young players coming through in positions where we have been thin in recent years. At 10 Beauden Barrett and Tom Taylor are also part of the future. Steve continues to look ahead by bringing in Sam Cane even though he hasn’t been starting at the Chiefs. With Richie now 31, the coach has to give himself that cover.
And of all the young players coming through, Brodie Retallick has been perhaps most impressive of all. Canterbury must wonder how they let him go. That’s a surprise. Retallick has been outstanding and is going to play a great deal of international football. It is just a question of when. International football brings the best out of Ali Williams and he will probably get first crack.
With Piri Weepu struggling, Kerr-Barlow or Aaron Smith will probably start on the bench as the back-up for Ellis. In the pack Luke Whitelock and Brad Shields will have to wait a little longer. Their time may even by a couple of years away still, but it is all part of the evolution.
When I picked my first team Xavier Rush and Jono Gibbes were in the back row. They had both been playing well at Super 12 and were both captains of their franchises. But they didn’t last. Before long Jerry Collins and Rodney So’oialo had come in. The beauty for Steve is that he doesn’t have to find his way. He has already been there for 8 years.
11 of the All Blacks 14 strong management team at the World Cup are back from last year. 20 of the World Cup squad are back, with several of the absent 10 either injured or retired. Steve has a wealth of experience there and he has brought in a lot of youngsters. He has the best of both worlds. Long live the evolution.
Posted under News & Opinions
about 1 year ago
I am just a retired Portuguese nr 10 but I dare to comment that leaving Fruean out would look like a joke if it was not an awful injustice and a terrible decision to New Zealand interests.
about 1 year ago
@Jose – Fruean is a good player but Conrad Smith, Nonu and SBW have all proven themselves at Test level. Fruean is a great runner with ball in hand but does not do enough work off it and needs to improve his defensive discipline.
about 1 year ago
@James – I Agree with you… He is definitely one for the future and I am sure AB management and Canterbury will be working hard with him to improve those areas! So much depth, it’s great to see…
about 1 year ago
Jose: Fruen has one very impressive outing every 7th or so game, against the Reds, he was hardly seen. Consistency has to be shown to make it into the AB’s. When on form, he’s outstanding.
about 1 year ago
Thank you all for the replies. Fruean can of course improve but right now I would prefer him even to Conrad Smith, and when I see that yougsters like Barrett (who I think is very good) were picked l simply don’t understand why Fruean is out. More so this being a relatively unimportant occasion that would be perfect to launch new talent. As I see things the AB’s would gain in having explosion instead of defense solidity in its backline.
about 1 year ago
I see the Freuan omission as simply being conservative. Freuan seems like a guy who is almost fully cooked, but still underdone. He is still developing and probably has some identified shortcoming that pose a risk at test level (My guess is lateral movement in defense, big guys often struggle there). The selectors have surely noticed his form. It probably has more to do with the mix on the pitch, and not making a rash selection based on popular opinion that could cost the team.
about 1 year ago
I would have liked to see Robbie Fruean in the Black Guernsey this year and I guess that the oppurtuinty may still exist down the track. All reasoning aside, expert or otherwise, he should have been included in the wider training group.
12 months ago
Conrad Smith have missed more tackles than Fruean this season. Just love it one one hear a term or a possible weakness of a player and they run of with it. Do I think Fruean deserve selection? No. He is missing a lot of times in the tougher games and scoring a lot of tries do not make you a selection certainty. Fruean got a lot of years ahead of him and he will know where to approve and I think we will see him in a AB jumper in the future. But the moment experience are needed in a AB squad building ahead with a big mix of youngsters in it.














8
Comments