Jimmy Cowan cashes in at England’s expense
Good luck to Jimmy Cowan. The All Black is off to Gloucester next season and is just the sort of nuggety player that you want to have on your side. The Shed will love him. If there is a scrap, the odds are that Jimmy will be in the middle of it, outraged and wild-eyed, swinging away at some bloke nearly twice his side.
To use that well-worn sporting euphemism, Jimmy is a competitor. He would probably upend the table in the pub if he lost a game of dominoes. If he hadn’t become a rugby player, he would be one of the boys getting drunk on a Saturday night, looking for a fight to punch out the demons. Correction. Even as a rugby player, Jimmy got into the occasional boozy brawl until Graham Henry and the All Blacks told him to get help or get out.
Henry tells the Rugby Site: “You have a responsibility as a coach to help your players. Jimmy Cowan is a prime example of a person who has made it. He had challenges in life that he had to work through. He is now highly respected and one of the most popular players in the squad. Someone who has nailed it, like Jimmy did, can be a good resource to help others.”
The question is just what help will Jimmy be to English rugby. The arrival of Cowan is another signing that will do absolutely no good for the English game. A few years ago Justin Marshall arrived at the end of his career, put a bit of cash away for retirement and went back to New Zealand having brought no value to English rugby.
Look around the Premiership. Bath and Saracens have South Africans at number 9, Sale a Welshman and Newcastle have turned to a 34-year-old Irishman. London Irish have just recruited Tomas O’Leary, Exeter have a handy Samoan and Wasps have just signed up an Australian. With Cowan now joining Gloucester after the departure of their Scotsman, there are not too many Englishmen learning their trade in the Premiership.
Please don’t let the clubs con you that they have any interest in the welfare of England’s national side however much they would like to be subsidised by its earnings. The development of players in the New Zealand franchises (one overseas player allowed) is thrilling at the moment and a big reason behind Cowan’s move.
Cowan has lost his place at the Highlanders to Aaron Smith who might just become the best number 9 to represent the All Blacks since Graeme Bachop. The Hurricanes have a young kid in TJ Perenara who is coming through. The Chiefs have Tawera Kerr-Barlow. Andy Ellis is playing the best rugby of his life at the Crusaders and one day in the next three years Piri Weepu might get fit again.
The game is vibrant and Cowan knows that it is about to pass him by. That is what happens at top level sport. Unless you are a rugby player. Then you can go to England or France and collect your pension at the expense of young local talent.
Jimmy’s never been the greatest passer in the world and he has been getting worse in the past 12 months. He has never terrified defences with his running game. But he reads the game well, defends strongly and is one of the best kicking 9’s in world rugby. The Gloucester backline won’t benefit from Jimmy’s arrival and nor will English rugby. Still, never mind any of that, Jimmy will be a folk hero for the Shed and he will return home a richer man.
Posted under News & Opinions
about 1 year ago
Jimmy did his service to NZ Rugby. He has been a live wire and produced some classic moments in his time. I wish him well in Europe, where in my opinion the game is slower and guys that are ‘older’ can still play at their tempo and remain fresh.
about 1 year ago
The great thing about Jimmy is that he never took a step backwards and was always brilliant against the Boks. It’s a shame his passing went ‘west’ in the RWC because this time last year he was easily the best 9 in the NZ Super 15 sides. I’m sure Gloucester will get great service from him, I wish him all the best
about 1 year ago
I hadn’t noticed there was a shortage of decent, English first-fives: you’ve got Danny Care, Joe Simpson, and Ben Youngs, all under 25.
Justin Marshall played well in Europe, though his powers were clearly on the wane. Jimmy Cowan isn’t in his class, but he’s a decent player and will help Gloucester win. I wish him well.
about 1 year ago
Very accurate article. How will england develop great scrum halves if older no.9s from elsewhere can come along and displace local talent? Players need to play at a high level to develop and no one knows where they will come from…Rhys Priestland, anyone…?
about 1 year ago
“Please don’t let the clubs con you that they have any interest in the welfare of England’s national side however much they would like to be subsidised by its earnings.”
This is the biggest load of rubbish I have seen in a long long time. Do you actually know anything about English rugby? At all? How can you make this baseless comment when Harlequins, currently the top side in the Premiership, consistantly field 20 EQ players in their match day 23? When Quins, Leicester, Sarries, Gloucester, Bath and Sale have brilliant academies who are currently producing some of the most exciting English players we have seen in years?
Why would they have academies at all if they had no interest in the state of English rugby? Why would Saracens loan out Andy Farrell to an interim England set up over the course of the 6N, possibly to the detriment of their own club ambitions, if they didn’t care about the state of English National rugby?
I’m a Gloucester supporter, and I have no problem about signing Cowan when he’s just going to add experience to a fully English (mostly Gloucester Academy) backline. Did you just happen for forget about the existance of Joe Simpson (24, Wasps)), Ben Youngs (22, Leicester)), Ben Spencer (19, Sarries) and especially Dan Robson (20) who is, funnily enough, is a product of the Gloucester Academy? Cowan will no doubt be a brilliant asset and a wonderful opportunity for Robson to learn from his experience and knowledge.
This article is so full of holes it doesn’t even float for a second. Why the hell The Rugby Site allowed this to be posted is beyond me, because you quite clearly haven’t got the faintest idea what you’re talking about.













5
Comments