Popular Topics:

Defence, Kicking, Breakdown, Set Piece

Young Kiwi number tens show England the way

Default
nz
Small

Wayne Smith

Chiefs Technical Advisor

over 1 year ago

Dan Carter will miss the first few weeks of the Super 15, but his absence has just highlighted the amazing strength in depth that New Zealand has in his position. If Wales has a fly-half factory then New Zealand has a global export industry.

Just for fun I have jotted down a list of Kiwi names (clue: three are now resident Aussies) who could challenge for the English fly-half position. You will find them at the end of the piece. I might have pushed the envelope a little in coming up with 19, but not by much. Some have argued that New Zealand won the World Cup with their seventh choice number 10 on the field.

One reason for the All Blacks remarkable depth in the position is that we do not have a rugby import industry. Regulations prohibit us from bringing in players from overseas so we are reliant on developing our own talent. Rugby also gets the first choice of athletic ability whereas in England maybe soccer has priority.

Players are developed through junior clubs, then through schools, age group rugby, ITM Cup, Super Rugby and the All Blacks. There is a progressive structure with high quality coaches at every level, many of whom have been in the job for 20 years.

A lot of them know what they are talking about because rugby is ingrained in our society. Everyone talks about the sport and that generates game understanding from a young age. You could walk into a coffee shop in New Zealand and overhear two women talking about the technical and tactical reasons that Piri Weepu missed a last minute drop goal against the Crusaders. They know the game.

That knowledge was so evident in the first week of the Super 15. Beauden Barrett is still only 20 but he played in South Africa against the Stormers with great composure. The Hurricanes pack was being pumped, but Barrett still conjured up two tries, kicked all his goals and defended the line. Barrett has great running ability as he has shown in sevens and he is going to be big.

Chris Noakes was technically excellent for the Highlanders. Aaron Cruden was very good defensively for the Chiefs and we know, like Colin Slade, he is an electric runner. Tyler Bleyendaal was strong and showed a good tactical kicking game. Michael Hobbs is a tough tackling five eighth who takes it to the line. The average age of the Kiwi five who started the first week of Super 15 is 22.

It is hard to imagine that happening in the Premiership in England where I coached for a while. There is a lad called George Ford at Leicester who is about to turn 19. He has huge potential, but how long will it be before he starts to play regular top grade rugby.

Our guys move around. In New Zealand Ford would have been drafted by someone else by now. He has had a few games for Leeds, but I just hope that a club out there will be prepared to show confidence in a young guy. Backing up Toby Flood is not going to help his game for long.

When I went to Northampton the ten played in the pocket, with deep alignment outside. We persuaded Paul Grayson to come out of semi retirement. He is one of the best I have coached. He had incredible hand, eye, foot coordination. It didn’t matter if it was darts or cricket, he was a natural. Grayson could take a flat ball and move it away with ease. But Grayson wasn’t developed at a young age into the player he could and should have been.

At the time, 2001, England was playing the best international rugby in the world, but it wasn’t being replicated at club level. There was a lot of safety first rugby. That is still the case and it is of no help to the England team. Until England finds a way to properly develop young talent, as happens in New Zealand, they will not exploit their population advantage.

New Zealand’s First-Five Industrial Revolution: Dan Carter, Quade Cooper, Nick Evans, Colin Slade, Aaron Cruden, James O’Connor, Stephen Donald, Piri Weepu, Beauden Berrett, Tyler Bleyendaal, Mike Harris, Gareth Anscombe, Michael Hobbs, Stephen Brett, Chris Noakes, Lima Sopoaga, Dan Kirkpatrick, Matt Berquist, Fletcher Smith

Get notified of more articles like this

We frequently post interesting articles and comment from our world class content providers so please provide us with your email address and we will notify you when new articles are available. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Posted under News & Opinions

11

Comments

gb
Missing-small

Report as inappropriate

Manuka Wood

over 1 year ago

20. Luke McAlistair

gb
Missing-small

Report as inappropriate

Manuka Wood

over 1 year ago

21. Jimmy Gopperth

za
Small

Report as inappropriate

S Spooony

over 1 year ago

My only question is how good would they be without such a great pack in front of them, and how often do they play under real pressure form the opposition- They main pressure probably comes from the standards set by the AB’s.

gb
Missing-small

Report as inappropriate

Manuka Wood

over 1 year ago

22. James Arlidge (Japan) this is fun.

English fly halves make it inspite of the system. That makes them really special as you saw in Grayson
gb
Missing-small

Report as inappropriate

richie barker

over 1 year ago

Excellent article but i would just say that in terms of english fly halves things are improving a bit: this article would have been completely accurate a year ago. George ford is starting to get first team action at 18 years old at leicester, the biggest club in england (btw i’m a saints fan with fond memories of your time as coach). Owen farrell at 20 is in the national side and to add to that we have two more goal kicking fly halves rory clegg at harlequins and freddie burns at gloucester are 22 and 21 featuring prominently for their clubs. the salary cap in the premiership is helping: clubs can not afford to import world class fly halves anymore. He may have only been 7th choice but it was a massive shock to us all when stephen donald ended up in the world cup final, he looks out of his depth even at club level over here

gb
Missing-small

Report as inappropriate

Manuka Wood

over 1 year ago

Here here. Right now Wilkinson would be 5 choice but might make the ABs bench.

gb
Small

Report as inappropriate

David Baldwin

over 1 year ago

Nick Evans is a fantastic No10.

gb
Missing-small

Report as inappropriate

richie barker

over 1 year ago

Had a go at ranking the england fly halves: Farrell-Flood-Wilkinson-Hodgson-Lamb-Cipriani-Barkley-Myler-Goode-Burns-Geraghty-Vesty-Twelvetrees-Clegg-Ford

au
Small

Report as inappropriate

David Gray

over 1 year ago

I expect to get hammered for these comments. I think if we were short of an international 2nd five and the selectors decided to move him out one posi then he would also be the best in the world having said that if he moved to fullback he’d end up the number 1 fullback as well. Weepu Ellis and Jimmy would start shaking in their boots if he turned up at training with number 9 on his back just for a laugh

gb
Small

Report as inappropriate

Simon Halliday

over 1 year ago

Wayne , great to hear your thoughts .I completely agree – George Ford had an outing recently for Leicester and won the game for them . He should leave now and find another club , Bath would be ideal as he could return them to the days where the midfield would enjoy quick ball and use it effectively – two of the best open field runners ever to play England No 10 were Bath men,Stuart Barnes and John Horton ….and they helped out one or two centres i can think of !

Hope you are really well – Help for Heroes week still brings a smile to my face …….SKY has featured one of the S Hemisphere tries as one of the seasons best !!

Regards to all in one of my favourite destinations !

za
Small

Report as inappropriate

S Spooony

over 1 year ago

I thought Wilkinson retired? Do not worry if the AB won’t make use of them Australia will. But I was thinking the other day what has happened to England rugby cause here I see surnames like Botha in the team. That is getting desperate a bit like the Italians…..