Articles

Thorb's Referee Rankings: Finals Posted almost 5 years ago

GAME SCORE REFEREE RANKING
AUSTRALIA v WALES 21 – 18 W BARNES 7.0/10
NEW ZEALAND v FRANCE 8 – 7 C JOUBERT 7.5/10

BRONZE MEDAL PLAY-OFF
AUSTRALIA v WALES – W BARNES
7.0/10

  1. The Wales scrum weighing a total of 925 kg (compared to Australia at 909 kg) was under extreme pressure for most of the game. It appears that the loss of Adam Jones reduced Welsh scrum ability significantly. Cadence was slow early on in game which was a little unsettling for both “packs”.
  2. There were 14 penalties at breakdown/ruck/post tackle (compared to his average over his 5 games of 11; 9—5—13—14—14.) He was consistent and fair at the breakdown, but this was a very untidy game (not the referees “doing”) with the Welsh in particular being loose in their ball carriage, presentation and security.
  3. 18 awarded in the game, which is around average for all referees over all the games.
  4. As in the Wales v Fiji game, a blatant forward pass missed by all 3 “officials” leading directly to Shane Williams’ try. Barnes was offline so it was a difficult ‘call’ for him however this “try” took Wales to an 8-7 lead.

GRAND FINAL
NEW ZEALAND v FRANCE – C JOUBERT
7.5/10

  1. A very tense and closely contested game where Jouberts calm seemingly unflappable manner was needed.
  2. Both teams were pushing the boundaries at the Breakdown, with the French very efficiently and frequently slowing the ball down.
  3. At the breakdown/ruck/post tackle he blew 12 penalties (5 against NZ and 7 against France) which was about average for the tournament.
  4. The seemingly lack of “input” from assistant referees Rolland and Owens, particularly at offside in phase play, skewed throws into lineout and knock on in general play seemed to be carrying on. This appears to follow a trend toward non-interference from the assistant referees over the RWC. This is not necessarily a bad thing, the question we need to be asking is “how much imput is too much?”
  5. Just 1 scrum reset in the game (NZ) and 4 penalties (2 each) – first scrum at 17 minute mark and just 2 scrums in the first 30 minutes (a total of 13 scrums in the whole game.)
  6. Jouberts consistency was a benefit to the game in that a “Rogue” penalty late in the game did not decide the Cup.
  7. Weighing all requirements for such an important contest, Craig Joubert was the best choice on form at the tournament.

Enter your email address to continue reading

We frequently post interesting articles and comment from our world class content providers so please provide us with your email address and we will notify you when new articles are available.

We'll also get in touch with various news and updates that we think will interest you. We promise to not spam, sell, or otherwise abuse your address (you can unsubscribe at any time).

Comments

comments powered by Disqus

Thorb's is a former All Black selector, New Zealand Sevens coach and most recently head coach of the USA Eagles during the 2007 Rugby World Cup. He is a highly respected international coach and has been involved with the IRB coach and referee groups shaping and refining the laws of the game.

Comments
Topic News & Opinions
Applicable to Coaches  

Related articles

Wonderful Weekend of Rugby has all up and running again

Peter Thorburn takes an analytical look at the brilliant round one action from the Heinken Cup and wonders if we need to take steps to ensure a fair contest for the ball at the breakdown

Thorb's Referee Rankings: Semifinals

Peter Thorborn’s weekly ranking of referee performance during the Rugby World Cup. This week he looks at Rolland’s performance in Wales v France (including that red card) and Joubert’s in New Zealand v Australia.

Thorb's Referee Rankings: Quarter Finals

Peter Thorborn’s weekly ranking of referee performance during the Rugby World Cup. Were now at the business end of the tournament and some of the referees are having a marked impact on the matches they are officiating.

Thorb's Referee Rankings #4

Peter Thorborn’s weekly ranking of referee performance during the Rugby World Cup. Week four and final week of pool play sees Kaplan remain top and Pearson remain at the bottom of the leaderboard. Will be interesting to see who is selected to referee the quarters.

Thorb's Referee Rankings #3

Peter Thorborn’s weekly ranking of referee performance during the Rugby World Cup. Week three of the Cup Kaplan stays on top of the leaderboard based on his performances last week, but Thorb’s thinks that Barnes is snipping at his heels.